What is considered beating the red light?

[Philipkee]

If you have crossed the first set of lights at a junction and the lights turned red before you completed the crossing, should you stop before the second set of lights at the other end of the junction or just proceed?

For context, I am referring to the junction of woodlands ave 12 to SLE in the direction of BKE.  Cars turn right from woodlands ave 12 to SLE up the filter lane

I notice sometimes some car will breakdown on the filter lane and cars turning right have to stop in between the first set of lights and the second set of lights as they try to wiggle past the broken down vehicle.  Then the lights turn red, which means the green man will come on.

Some cars will still proceed (if there are no pedestrians) cos they are already mid junction.  Some cars will just stop which means their boots will now go beyond the boundary of the yellow box and obstruct vehicles exiting the SLE to woodlands ave 12.

So who is right?  Those who proceeded or those who stopped?

I remember BTT say once you cross the first set of traffic lights you cross the second set as well and not stop in the middle of the junction

[encourageSome1]

If you have crossed the first set of lights at a junction and the lights turned red before you completed the crossing, should you stop before the second set of lights at the other end of the junction or just proceed?

For context, I am referring to the junction of woodlands ave 12 to SLE in the direction of BKE.  Cars turn right from woodlands ave 12 to SLE up the filter lane

I notice sometimes some car will breakdown on the filter lane and cars turning right have to stop in between the first set of lights and the second set of lights as they try to wiggle past the broken down vehicle.  Then the lights turn red, which means the green man will come on.

Some cars will still proceed (if there are no pedestrians) cos they are already mid junction.  Some cars will just stop which means their boots will now go beyond the boundary of the yellow box and obstruct vehicles exiting the SLE to woodlands ave 12.

So who is right?  Those who proceeded or those who stopped?

I remember BTT say once you cross the first set of traffic lights you cross the second set as well and not stop in the middle of the junction

To me is should safely complete yr turn so as not to obstruct
But for ah mah eye clarity pls show pic

[No guessing game]

See Red light die die must stop. See whether they want  charge u if u never stop

[Philipkee]

To me is should safely complete yr turn so as not to obstruct
But for ah mah eye clarity pls show pic

The red circle.  If you happen to cross the junction but you are stopped temporarily in the red circle and the lights turn red, can you proceed to complete the crossing?

It feels weird to continue cos it's like beating the red light but if you don't complete, you obstruct oncoming traffic to an extent and you are supposed to complete the crossing.  We don't stop in the middle of T junctions or square junctions just because the lights change mid junction.

[encourageSome1]

The red circle.  If you happen to cross the junction but you are stopped temporarily in the red circle and the lights turn red, can you proceed to complete the crossing?

It feels weird to continue cos it's like beating the red light but if you don't complete, you obstruct oncoming traffic to an extent and you are supposed to complete the crossing.  We don't stop in the middle of T junctions or square junctions just because the lights change mid junction.

then should complete
Else u causing danger to coming traffic and to urself

[No guessing game]

The red circle.  If you happen to cross the junction but you are stopped temporarily in the red circle and the lights turn red, can you proceed to complete the crossing?

It feels weird to continue cos it's like beating the red light but if you don't complete, you obstruct oncoming traffic to an extent and you are supposed to complete the crossing.  We don't stop in the middle of T junctions or square junctions just because the lights change mid junction.

In this case can. U can't possibly stop in the middle of the road ma

[Philipkee]

then should complete
Else u causing danger to coming traffic and to urself

I see many people stop.  And I start to wonder

I was joking with my bro I should ask TP then I joke maybe they ask what I have done before and then send a summons letter based on my answer

[default]

Cross red light means ur vehicle nv go past the line when light turns red

[default]

U cannot stop in the middle la. By right there will be a signal for u to turn right de what

[No guessing game]

I see many people stop.  And I start to wonder

I was joking with my bro I should ask TP then I joke maybe they ask what I have done before and then send a summons letter based on my answer

This case can stop inside yellow box

[encourageSome1]

I see many people stop.  And I start to wonder

I was joking with my bro I should ask TP then I joke maybe they ask what I have done before and then send a summons letter based on my answer

I think they shd retake their theory and tp should cover it in theory when they should not stop
Example case is this one
If stop more accidents and more risk

[Philipkee]

U cannot stop in the middle la. By right there will be a signal for u to turn right de what

No.  This junction is like a two way junction.

Woodlands ave 12, you curve right to go up SLE in direction of BKE

Coming from SLE, you come down the slope and curve right to go to Woodlands Ave 12

[Philipkee]

A top down view of the junction



The arrows are the only two directions traffic can go and because they intersect, only one side can go at any one time so there is no arrow or anything.  Just green light or red light

[Philipkee]

I think they shd retake their theory and tp should cover it in theory when they should not stop
Example case is this one
If stop more accidents and more risk

I think some people think this can be considered as an "island".  Similar example exist in Bukit Merah.  Turning right from CMPB to mt Faber Safra junction

[Philipkee]

This case can stop inside yellow box

If so, no one can exit SLE liao.